Comparing Acumatica vs Microsoft Dynamics SL

Microsoft Dynamics SL (formerly Solomon) is a mid-market ERP product that integrates financial management specifically designed for project- and service-based companies.

Acumatica also has rich ERP functionality with strong Project Accounting capabilities. But unlike Dynamics SL, Acumatica was designed from the start to be accessible through the cloud and mobile technology. This lets Acumatica offer more features and functions than Dynamics SL at a lower long-term price.

See how Acumatica compares with Dynamics SL:

 

Functionality Acumatica Microsoft Dynamics SL
True cloud (built for cloud)
Full function ERP
Full relational database export
Flexible licensing options (subscription and perpetual)
Multiple deployment options (cloud, on premise, hybrid)
Scale as you grow
Lower Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)
IMG Enterprises Migrated from Microsoft Dynamics SL to Acumatica
"From being able to enter orders and production information directly in the field, to minimizing travel time, saving on vehicles, saving on fuel, there’s a lot of things Acumatica will make a big difference with."

Jim Lieffort,
Director of Planning & IT

For project-based companies, Acumatica provides project cost tracking, time and expense management, field service automation, and integrated financials. Acumatica also handles retainage, commitments, budgets, change management, subcontracts and more.

For a more in-depth comparison, read “A Side-by-Side Comparison: Acumatica Project Accounting vs. Microsoft Dynamics SL” by Todd Delaney.

Significant differentiators between Acumatica and Dynamics SL

True cloud: “True cloud” means all functionality is accessible through the internet using a standard browser without the need for any additional software installation on the user’s device or additional software licensing. Acumatica works on premises or in the cloud without additional equipment or software. Dynamics SL requires Microsoft SharePoint as a frontend for it to run in the cloud. Currently, the only true cloud option offered by Microsoft for SL users today is to give up SL entirely and reimplement (at significant expense) with Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central (formerly Dynamics NAV).

Multiple deployment options: Technically, both products support cloud, on-premises, and hybrid configurations. However, Acumatica supports all three deployment options natively using a browser to access the system. Dynamics SL, on the other hand, requires SharePoint as a front-end to enable a cloud configuration. In addition, SharePoint requires user licensing, increasing TCO.

Scale as you grow: When choosing an ERP solution, you must consider not just your company’s current needs, but the future needs as well. Both products allow you to scale resources to support a growing company, but because Acumatica only charges by the computing power required and not by users, you can scale your equipment as you grow, allowing an unlimited number of users to access the system regardless of job function. Dynamics SL, on the other hand, incurs greater costs as your company grows and more employees need access to the system. Be aware of these costs and consider them in your final evaluation.

TCO: Acumatica charges by computing resources used, not by user. Dynamics SL charges per user, and these costs increase as your company grows. Moreover, Acumatica works natively in the cloud, where Dynamics SL requires a separate license for SharePoint for it to work in the cloud.

Use Acumatica’s pricing tool to find out the real cost of moving to a modern ERP system. Calculate ROI and total cost of ownership for any ERP. Including Microsoft Dynamics SL.

About Microsoft Dynamics SL

While Microsoft Dynamics SL continues to be a very good mid-market ERP product, there are some drawbacks. For example:

  • Dynamics SL still uses an aging client-server architecture, and requires Microsoft SharePoint to run in the cloud.
  • Dynamics SL requires the purchase of additional Microsoft products (CRM, SharePoint, Project Server, etc.) to take full advantage of its capabilities.
  • Dynamics SL’s much older system architecture becomes an issue in scenarios designed for the latest technologies, including cloud deployment options, customizations using current development tools, and integration with CRM.
  • SL users can expect less innovation for their maintenance dollar. Microsoft has said, “Dynamics GP and Dynamics SL will continue to receive product improvements and updates, but the most benefit to these customers comes from upgrading to Dynamics 365 Business Central”
  • SL has no direct migration path to Business Central, Microsoft’s only true-cloud mid-market ERP product. Moving to Business Central will be a new implementation on a different ERP.

Solomon was acquired by Great Plains Software in June 2000. Great Plains was subsequently acquired by Microsoft Corporation in May 2001. Microsoft has stopped actively marketing Microsoft SL. Currently, all the development and support for Dynamics SL has been outsourced.

Acumatica offers a completely integrated ERP and CRM solution and can be deployed on premises or in the cloud. The cost for Acumatica is based on the price of system resources, not by the number of users, so you enjoy unlimited users as your company grows.

We believe Acumatica provides the best price/value, performance, functionality, and ease of use of any ERP product available for small- and medium-sized businesses. We encourage you to perform due diligence when considering the purchase of any ERP system, not just ours. Ask questions. Know your business requirements over the next three to five years. We want to make sure you get the ERP system that is right for your company now and in the future.

NOTE: John Howell was the CEO of Solomon from 1983-1999 and the co-founder of Acumatica. Those that like the functionality of Dynamics SL will find many similarities with Acumatica.

See the G2 Crowd survey showing how users compared Acumatica against Microsoft Dynamics NAV, GP, and 365.

Make sure you take some time to review Acumatica’s ERP software selection resources to help you find the solution that is right for you.

Watch this quick (3 minute) demonstration of Acumatica in action.

What our customers are saying after replacing Dynamics SL with Acumatica?

Calculate the cost of replacing your ERP system

Use Acumatica’s pricing tool to find out the real cost of moving to a modern ERP system. Calculate ROI and total cost of ownership for any ERP.